1. The decision that the Defendant rendered the Intervenor joining the Defendant as the elected person at the sixth president election that was held on December 8, 2015.

1. Basic facts

A. The defendant is an incorporated association established for the purpose of promoting the welfare of B enterprisers and protecting their rights and interests, and the chairman, who is the representative of the defendant, shall be elected by indirect election by representatives elected by each

The Defendant prescribed the specific procedures and methods for the election of the chief director as the "election regulations for the chief director" (hereinafter referred to as "election regulations").

(b) The main parts related to the election campaign and the decision on the elected persons among the election regulations shall be as follows:

Article 10 (Election Campaign)

2. An election campaign shall not be carried out on the election day;

4. An election campaign by means of documents, printed materials, advertisements, etc. shall not be carried out prior to the registration of candidate.

5. The election period shall begin from the date of registration of candidate to the day preceding the election.

Article 21 (Decision on and Notice of Elected Persons)

1. The election of the chief director shall be made in multiple votes as a result of voting;

4. The chairperson of the election management shall declare the number of votes obtained and a winner of a candidate, and immediately notify the elected person thereof;

5. Even after an election is held, if any ground for disqualification occurs in violation of Articles 6 and 10, the election shall be invalidated;

C. On November 3, 2015, following the expiration of the Plaintiff’s term of office, Defendant Election Commission announced the election to elect the sixth president.

The Plaintiff, the Intervenor joining the Defendant (hereinafter “ Intervenor”) and D registered the candidate for chief director. D.

On December 8, 2015, the Defendant held a temporary representative meeting for the election of the chief director (hereinafter “instant election”). From 09:30 to 10:40 on the same day, the Intervenor distributed approximately 120 copies of the printed matter (Evidence No. 5; hereinafter “instant printed matter”) in which the Intervenor’s election pledge, etc. is entered to representatives outside the entrance of the first floor of the building at the general meeting place.

E. In the instant election, the Intervenor acquired each valid vote of 62 votes, 61 votes, and 24 votes by the Plaintiff, and the chairman of the Defendant Election Commission on December 8, 2015.