1. A claim for a patent D invention among a trial decision rendered by the Intellectual Property Tribunal on October 31, 2016 on the case No. 2014Dang2462.

1. Basic facts

A. (1) On October 2, 2014, the Defendant filed a petition for invalidation trial against the Plaintiff on October 2, 2014, and claimed that the Plaintiff’s patent invention described in the following (b) was null and void as there is no inventive step. (2) On December 26, 2014, the Plaintiff deleted the patent claim 2 of the instant patent invention, and filed a petition for correction of the content that adds the matters described in the claim 2 to the claim 1, an independent claim (hereinafter “instant correction”).

3) On October 31, 2016, the Korean Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board deliberated on the amendment as 2014Da2462 and deliberated on October 31, 2016, the amendment of the instant case is lawful, but the amendment is lawful, and the amendment of the instant claim (hereinafter “instant amendment invention”).

) A trial ruling citing a request for a trial on the ground that the nonobviousness is denied by a combination of prior inventions 1 or 3 with prior inventions 1 or 3 (hereinafter “instant trial ruling”).

(B) The trial decision of this case rejected a request for a trial as to the claim 2 deleted following the correction of this case. (B) The name of the invention of this case (Evidence (Evidence (Evidence (No. 3) 1): E2; the filing date / the registration date / the patent registration number : F/G/D 3: the patentee: the plaintiffs 4) claims prior to the correction of this case)

1.The one side of the conical trend towing the conical direction of the drilling No. 1; the one side of the conical direction; the one side of the conical direction of the drilling No. 4 or 5; and the one side of the conical direction of the conical direction, including the one side of the conical direction; the one side of the spinal structure improvement and treatment of the spine structure; the one side of the conical direction and the one side of the conical direction, with the characteristics of including multiple conical renals; the other side of the conical direction and the other side of the conical direction, are the two sub

2. With respect to claims 1, the height angles of the parallel 1 above and the parallel scopic scopic scopic scopic scopic scopic scopic scopic scopic scopic scopic scop

3. (Omission Claim) Claim;

4. Claim 1: