1. All appeals filed by the plaintiffs and the claims extended by this court are dismissed.

2. After an appeal is filed.

1. Basic facts

A. E, the Defendant, and F’s G co-operation 1) E in the name of Dong students I on May 1, 1995, G (former trade name: K; hereinafter “G”) in the Nam-gu, Incheon. J on May 1, 1995

(1) The Plaintiff testified to the effect that the Defendant’s testimony was 3.3% since May 1, 1995 to December 30, 2006, the proportion of shares in the same business as E, F, and Defendant G is 3.3%, respectively. However, the witness of the first instance court set the same ratio as 33.3% for the first time, while the E, F, and Defendant were changed to 40%, Defendant 20%, and that the changed ratio of shares was maintained until the Defendant withdraws from G. The Plaintiffs testified to the effect that the Defendant’s testimony was 20% based on the evidence No. 20, E, F, and Defendant’s testimony as the date of withdrawal from G. 36%, respectively.

The plaintiffs asserted that the time when the defendant withdraws from G is December 30, 2006 according to the statement in Gap evidence No. 2, and that the defendant does not dispute this. Thus, the defendant's G withdrawal time is to be determined on the basis of the plaintiffs' claims.

G was withdrawn from the operation of G, and thereafter E and F operated 40% and 60% of G from December 31, 2006.

E, as the E withdraws from the operation of G on February 28, 2007, the F independently operated G from March 1, 2007 to July 31, 2013, and closed G on July 31, 2013.

B. The defendant, E, the defendant, and F L joint operation 1), together with F and M from January 16, 1997, L (the trade name before the change: O.