1. The plaintiffs' appeals against the defendants are all dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal are assessed against the Plaintiffs.

1. The facts subsequent to the facts of recognition do not conflict between the parties, or may be acknowledged in Gap evidence No. 1 by integrating the whole purport of the pleadings.

1) H and the Plaintiff A and B are South-North relationship. 2) Plaintiff C is the marital relationship with Plaintiff B.

3) Defendant D is in a natural relationship with Defendant F, and is the mother of Defendant E. 4) Defendant F is the mother of Defendant G.

B. Defendant D was indicted by the Daegu District Court 2016Ma78 on the following criminal facts (hereinafter “instant criminal facts”), and Defendant E, G, and F was suspended from indictment.

At around 18:00 on February 18, 2015, the Defendant, along with Defendant E, G, and F, tried to divide the first race and find out H suspected of having a bad faith relationship with K, the husband of the Defendant.

Accordingly, the victim A (the 54 years of age) who was in the above Jho was living out of the house, and the defendant was living out of H, not the house of H.

이에 피고인은 피해자 원고 A의 뺨을 때리고, 피고 E은 피해자 원고 A의 팔을 꺾고 목을 조르고, 이어서 피고인은 발로 피해자 원고 A의 머리를 차고, 피고 F은 발로 피해자 원고 A의 옆구리를 수 회 찼다.

그 후 피고인은 현장에 도착한 피해자 원고 C(65세)으로부터 “누구십니까”라는 이야기를 듣자, “내가 K 마누라다”라고 하면서 손바닥으로 피해자 원고 C의 뺨을 때리고, 피고 E은 피해자 원고 C의 멱살을 잡고, 피고 G은 발로 피해자 원고 C의 허리 부위와 팔, 다리를 수 회 찼다.

The Defendant and Defendant F continued to catch the head debt of the Plaintiff B (n, 61 years of age), which arrive at the scene with the Plaintiff C, and the Defendant E and the Defendant G met with the face of the Plaintiff B, the chest and her arms and legs, and the bridge.

As a result, the defendant is jointly with the defendant E, G, and F, and the victim A needs to be treated for about four weeks.