1. The judgment of the first instance court is modified upon the Plaintiff’s request changed at the trial court as follows.

The defendant.

In fact, the defendant is a branch of the Korean Automobile Trade Union under the Korean Federation of Workers' Unions, which consists of members who have joined the above trade union from among the workers of Co., Ltd. C.

The plaintiffs are the defendant's members.

[Reasons for Recognition] The absence of dispute, Article 14 (Keeping Documents, etc.) (1) of the Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act (hereinafter “Trade Union Act”) related to the determination of Gap’s evidence No. 1 (hereinafter “Trade Union Act”)

1. List of union members (in case of a trade union in the form of an associated organization, the name of its constituent organization);

2. Union bylaws;

3. A list of names and addresses of executives;

4. Minutes;

(2) The documents referred to in paragraph (1) 4 and 5 shall be preserved for three years.

Article 25 (Audit of Accounts) (1) The representative of a trade union shall have an auditor conduct an audit of all financial resources of the trade union and their uses, names of major contributors, current financial and accounting status, etc. at least once every six months, and shall disclose the details thereof to all the union members.

(2) The auditor of the trade union may, if necessary, conduct an accounting audit of the trade union and disclose its results.

Article 26 (Disclosure of Status of Operation) The representative of a trade union shall make a report on the settlement of accounts and the current status of operation each fiscal year, and shall make it available for inspection at the request of its members

The books and documents concerning finance referred to in Article 14 (1) 5 of the Enforcement Rule of the Trade Union Act shall be as follows:

1. The budget;

2. Statement of accounts;

3. President of the gross revenue and president of the total expenditure;

4. Revenue or expenditure resolution;

5. Revenue-related books and documentary evidence; and

6. Expenditure-related books and documentary evidence; and

7. Article 14 of the Trade Union Act regarding the Plaintiffs’ request for access to self-accounting audit-related documents.