1. The part of the judgment of the court of first instance against the plaintiff, which orders payment below, shall be revoked.

The defendant.

1. Basic facts

A. The Plaintiff is a company that engages in insurance agency business upon concluding an entrustment contract with the Plaintiff Intervenor E (hereinafter “E”). The Defendant is an insurance solicitor who entered into an entrustment contract with the Plaintiff from December 2008 to July 2014 and performed the business of mediating the conclusion of an insurance contract and receiving premiums.

Article 1 (Purpose) The purpose of the contract is to determine necessary matters in the performance of affairs delegated by an insurance solicitor registered in the company (Plaintiff) to the company, such as brokerage of the conclusion of a contract for goods of life insurance companies and non-life insurance companies under contract with the company, receipt of insurance premiums and affairs incidental thereto.

Article 7(1) The Company shall pay or recover an allowance to an insurance solicitor as provided for in the commissioning Contract (Payments 3) (Payment and Redemption of Allowances). (2) The Company shall sufficiently explain to the insurance solicitor (payment and Redemption of Allowances) the essential contents of the commission contract within seven days after the conclusion of the initial commissioning Contract, and shall receive from the insurance solicitor [verification of Important Explanations as to Payment of Allowances].

3) An insurance solicitor shall return any already paid allowance immediately upon occurrence of the cause for the refund of the allowances set forth in [the payment and redemption of allowances] such as invalidity, termination, quality assurance, cancellation, cancellation of order, and failure to maintain the opportunity for assistance, etc. of the insurance contract solicited by the insurance solicitor. Article 32 (Composition of Fees) 1) The fees that the company pays to the insurance solicitor are:

(1) Two scholarship allowances and two different commissions are based on the settlement records of life insurance adjusted with weight compared to the conversion records for life insurance products and insurance companies. The subscription records for non-life insurance are calculated based on the adjustment records of non-life insurance adjusted with weight compared to the corrected results for each insurance company.