1. Of the judgment of the first instance, the plaintiff against the defendant Republic of Korea and Guro-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government who ordered payment below.

1. Basic facts

A. Plaintiff clan’s status 1) L’s 19th hand of M M, which was the 19th hand of M, P, Q, and R’s 3th hand of P, Q, and R, but Q and R were separated. The Plaintiff clan was composed of only P’s descendants in fact as a clan for the purpose of the strawing, the protection of graves, and the management of the soil and sand by the descendants of P, who were the descendants of theO. However, P, as the descendants of theO, was jointly set up as the O’s descendants (R and Q’s descendants were not identified, and all of the members of the Plaintiff clan were the descendants of the above P.

2) While T and U were the grandchildren of the above P, U had moved to the present Nam-gu Incheon Metropolitan City V (name of the land: W), and the descendants became the "X". The descendants of Y and Z as the grandchildren of the above T were the "AB", and the descendants of Z were the "AB", and the remaining descendants of Z constituted the plaintiff's clan because they were called the "AE" as they were called the "AE".

3) The plaintiff clan was first called the "L clan" but from around 1940 to clearly indicate the N's family coverage, the plaintiff clan was changed to the "AH" by attaching the six members of the NM and the four members of the AG in front of the N's name. 4) The plaintiff clan held a general meeting on October 15 of each year, which held a social assembly on October 15 of the 1980 and dealt with the church affairs of the clan. The plaintiff clan held an extraordinary clan meeting on June 14, 1980.

At the time, the president of the plaintiff clan, the president of the AI, notifies 109 members of the clan confirmed at the time that the plaintiff clan would hold an extraordinary meeting of the plaintiff clan on June 14, 1980, and notify 52 members present on the day, and 8 members who attended the meeting to consent to the resolution of the above general meeting, and 60 members, such as 52 members present on the day, and 8 members who submitted the power of attorney, shall attend the meeting and be appointed as the president of the clan, the name of the clan as "AL members", and the name of the clan shall be determined as "AL members."