1. The plaintiff's assistant intervenor's application for participation shall be dismissed.

2. The Defendant’s KRW 10,592,638,350 and the remainder thereof to the Plaintiff

(a) 8,139.

1. Basic facts

A. 1) Conclusion of a shipbuilding contract for a ship

) On September 6, 2007, Germany, a German corporation, and the Vastntain Sag Un’s Beteungs Gesske (Sagle Un’s Betegungs), and the client of this case (hereinafter “the client of this case”).

) Two vessels of Class 180,00DWW (ship number OSN-1015, OSN-1016, hereinafter referred to as “each of the instant vessels”).

2) The owner of the instant case agreed to pay USD 17,732,440 each time to the original vessel five times in accordance with the shipbuilding process, with the shipbuilding cost of the vessel (hereinafter “Advance”) at USD 88,662,200 per vessel.

B. 1) With respect to each shipbuilding contract of this case, the National Bank of Korea (hereinafter “National Bank”) is a Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “National Bank”).

(2) On January 14, 2008, when an advance refund accident occurred on January 14, 2008, the Defendant and the Plaintiff jointly take over an advance refund guarantee insurance (Refund Guante Inc., hereinafter “the instant raw water insurance”) that the Defendant who received the request of an original shipbuilding vessel notifies the Defendant that he will take over 80% of the raw water insurance of this case, and the remainder is taken over by the Plaintiff upon receipt of the request of the original shipbuilding). On the same day, the Defendant became the executive secretary of the National Bank, and the Plaintiff issued the instant insurance policy (Refund Guante Ltd., hereinafter “the instant raw water insurance”).

C. At the time of concluding the instant raw insurance contract, the Defendant, a domestic insurance broker, at the time of concluding the instant raw insurance contract.