1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

1. Basic facts

A. On September 8, 2015, the Defendant filed a petition against the Plaintiff for a trial for invalidation of the registration of the instant patent invention with the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board No. 2015Da4482. 2) On March 23, 2016, the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board rendered the instant trial ruling citing the Defendant’s request for a trial on invalidation of the registration of the instant patent invention on the ground that “the claim 1 through 4 of the instant patent invention can easily be made by a person with ordinary knowledge belonging to the instant patent invention by prior inventions 1 and 2 (hereinafter “ordinary technician”), and thus, the nonobviousness is denied.”

B. The Plaintiff’s title of the instant patent invention (A No. 3) invention: The filing date of channel separation electronic device/registration date/registration number: the filing date/registration number of the instant patent invention, which outlined the instant patent invention on September 16, 2010// April 14, 2011// 10-103069, refers to a device fixing a structure by using an electronic seat as a permanent electric power source.

It is related to channel separation type electronic control devices using the Corporation, which adopted control methods that can independently clamping the structure by the channel in accordance with the characteristics such as the size of the structure by shotizing all or part of electronic devices that clamping the structure in the processing machine.

(Identification Number [008] or [001]. Claims 1] : (a) in the case of a channel-type electronic control device consisting of a channel-based electronic control device consisting of a main control device that enables the former to independently operate in a number of channels by means of the above main control device, and a channel-based electronic control device that enables the former to independently operate in a number of channels by means of the control of the above main control device (hereinafter referred to as “group 1”), the above main fishing ground means, the electric source from the above main source input unit and the electric unit unit of each of the above channels (hereinafter referred to as “class 2-1”); (b) a current-based control center that reduces the source of the former unit input from the above main source input unit; (c) a current control center that reduces the source of the former unit input of each channel (hereinafter referred to as “class 2-1”);