Text
1. All appeals by the defendant against the plaintiffs are dismissed.
2. The costs of appeal shall be borne by the Defendant.
3. The judgment of the court of first instance is rendered.
Reasons
1. Scope of the judgment of this court;
A. Plaintiff A claimed KRW 169,455,927 in total (i) KRW 135,163,41 in daily actual income ( ② KRW 1,094,060 in the future treatment expenses ④ KRW 9,477,850 in the future treatment expenses ④ KRW 300,00 in the purchase expenses of assistive devices ⑤ KRW 300,420,60 in the nursing expenses ④ KRW 20,000 in the nursing expenses ② KRW 20,000 in the consolation money), Plaintiff B, and C in each of the above money, and damages for delay at an interest rate as stated in the claim.
B. The first instance court ordered the Plaintiff to pay the Plaintiff KRW 87,957,464 in total (i) KRW 69,806,054 in daily income (ii) KRW 734,060 in the future treatment expenses ③ KRW 4,417,350 in the future treatment expenses ④ KRW 00 in the purchase expenses of assistive devices ( KRW 6,417,350 in the nursing expenses) KRW 6,00 in the amount of solatium 13,00,000 in the amount of solatium 2,00,000 in each of the above amounts, and the damages for delay at the interest rate.
C. Of the judgment of the court of first instance, the Defendant appealed only to the part against the Defendant ordering payment of the Plaintiff in excess of the same period as claimed in the claim and the delay damages of interest rate as stated in the claim against the Plaintiff, and to the part against the Defendant against the Plaintiff, as well as the part against each of the Defendants against the Plaintiff and C.
Therefore, the scope of the court's adjudication is limited to the plaintiff A's claim for actual import of the plaintiff A, which is partially accepted by the court of first instance, which exceeds "1,897,576 won and the same period of time and damages for delay of interest rate" as the claim for such claim, and the plaintiff B and C's claim as partially accepted by the court of
2. The reasons for the lower court’s reasoning concerning this part of the facts of recognition and the occurrence of liability for damages are as follows: (a) Article 420 of the Civil Procedure Act of the first instance judgment, except that the lower court’s “as of March 13, 2013” (as of March 13, 2013, around 20:05) is deemed as “as of March 31, 2013.”
3. Determination as to Plaintiff A’s claim for lost income
(a) Evidence A, 7, 8, and 13-1.