Text
1. The plaintiff's lawsuit against defendant D and E shall be dismissed respectively.
2. The plaintiff's claim against the defendant B and C is dismissed, respectively.
3.
Reasons
1. Facts of recognition;
A. An ownership change process with respect to F 331 square meters at the time of the residence before the division (hereinafter “instant land”) is a F-31 square meters at the time of residence before the division (hereinafter “instant land before the division”).
B) On February 16, 1983, H acquired 1/2 shares each of the 1/2 shares around July 24, 1990. 2) On February 28, 1983, the Dog G completed the registration of ownership transfer based on sale on February 16, 2018, as regards F-ground Slaves and Gags and 17 square meters each of 17 square meters each of the instant buildings (hereinafter “the instant building”).
3) On December 13, 2004, the network G completed the registration of ownership transfer for 34/31 shares out of its own shares in the land prior to the instant subdivision to H on December 9, 2004, based on sale and purchase on December 9, 2004. 4) Defendant D and E completed the registration of ownership transfer for each share of 99.75/331 shares out of H shares in the land prior to the instant subdivision on September 30, 2014.
5) The deceased G died on May 30, 2014. At the time, the heir was the Plaintiff and Defendant B and C, the spouse of the deceased. B. The process of partition of the land prior to the partition of this case, 1) H filed a lawsuit against the Plaintiff, Defendant B and C with this court 2014 money281, and thereafter, succeeded to the said lawsuit after Defendant D and E acquired H’s shares.
(2) Around December 1, 2014, in a co-owned property partition lawsuit, around December 1, 2014, Defendant D, E, and C divided the land before the instant partition into South and North Korea, with the size of 132 square meters in north-west, and the remaining 199 square meters in common by the Plaintiff, Defendant B, and C, and the said decision became final and conclusive around that time. Accordingly, around March 20, 2015, the said decision became final and conclusive. As a result, around March 20, 2015, the land before the instant partition was divided into 199 square meters in common, and the area of the land before the instant partition remains 132 square meters in common.
(hereinafter referred to as “instant land”). D The Plaintiff, Defendant B, and C, from among the instant land around March 9, 2018, are the Plaintiff on May 2, 394.