1. Of the judgment of the court of first instance, the part against the defendant exceeding the following amount ordered to be paid shall be revoked.

1. Facts of recognition;

A. The Plaintiff is an urban gas company that supplies natural gas, and the Defendant from March 2003 to 702 Dong-dong 702 (hereinafter “instant housing”) from the Plaintiff to the date of the supply of urban gas.

B. The Plaintiff confirmed the usage of urban gas every month by checking the measuring instruments installed in the housing of the user, and supplied urban gas to the user by claiming usage fees. The Defendant did not comply with the checkup due to the absence of the housing in the instant case from December 2, 2008 to July 2015, and the Defendant claimed urban gas charges for the said period according to the following recognized notification method.

(2) The general urban gas business operators shall determine supply regulations and obtain approval therefor from the Mayor/Do governor.

The same shall also apply to any revision to approved matters.

Article 18 (Calculation of Quantity of Energy Use) (1) of the Urban Gas Supply Regulations of Seoul Special Metropolitan City (Calculation of Quantity of Gas Users) (1) Company shall determine the amount of use for the relevant month of gas users according to the "Public Notice on Application of Greenhouse-Pressure Revised Coefficient for Securing Appropriateness in Measurement of Quantity of Gas Supply" in the gas user's gas measuring instrument or greenhouse pressure correction device under Article 1

(3) Where a company cannot clearly measure the amount of use during the preceding year or the amount of use during the preceding month due to the absence of gas users, etc., the company shall calculate the amount of use during the preceding year as the amount of use during the preceding year or during the preceding month, and where it is impracticable to measure the amount of use during the preceding year due to other reasons, such as a failure of gas measuring instruments, in principle, it shall calculate the amount of use during the preceding year as the amount of monthly average use during the preceding month and the amount of

C. The value of the gas measuring instrument installed in the instant housing (hereinafter “instant measuring instrument”) (the quantity used shall be indicated as a unit of square meter) is four figures.