1. On June 15, 2015, the claims indicated in the separate sheet between the defendant and the non-party GaelS Co., Ltd. were concluded.

1. Determination as to the occurrence of obligee's right of revocation

A. Determination 1 on the grounds of the claim

(2) On June 15, 2015, upon receipt of this Court’s order of payment for the purchase of goods under this Court No. 2015 tea3819 and filing an order of payment for the purchase of goods, “the debtor shall pay to the creditor an amount of KRW 294,646,141 per annum 20% per annum from the day after the payment order was served to the day of full payment.” The facts established on July 14, 2015 can be acknowledged by the statement of evidence No. 4. According to the above facts, the preserved claim is recognized. (2) According to the debtor’s fraudulent act and evidence No. 5 through No. 322 (including the provisional number), the assessed value of real estate, bonds, corporeal movables, etc. owned by the non-party company following the following legal act was approximately KRW 3.3 billion, and the non-party company shall be recognized as having transferred its obligation to the defendant under the attached list No. 515 billion (hereinafter “No. 2515 billion won”).

According to the above facts, the legal act of this case is presumed to constitute a fraudulent act because the non-party company, which has already been in excess of the obligation, transfers the claim of this case to the defendant among many creditors, and the joint collateral against the general creditor has decreased, and its intention is recognized, and as long as it is recognized as the intention of damage by the non-party company, the defendant's bad faith as the beneficiary is presumed.

3. On the judgment of the defendant's bona fide assertion, the defendant had a claim against the non-party company up to May 2015 to about KRW 147 million, and the defendant had a claim against the non-party company.