1. The decision made by the Intellectual Property Tribunal on December 12, 2018 by the Intellectual Property Tribunal on the case shall be revoked.

2. The costs of the lawsuit are assessed against the defendant.

1. Basic facts

가. 원고의 이 사건 출원상표(갑1호증) 1) 출원일/ 출원번호 : B/ C 2) 구 성 : 3) 지정상품 : 상품류 구분 제25류의 모자(headwear), 셔츠(shirts), 스웨터(sweaters), 조끼(vests), 하의(의복-bottoms), 드레스(dresses), 스커트(skirts), 운동용 유니폼(athletic uniforms), 저지(jerseys), 속옷(underwear or undergarments), 잠옷(sleepwear), 목욕가운(bath robes), 수영복(swimwear), 재킷(jackets), 판초(ponchos), 에이프런(aprons-clothing), 랩(의류-wraps [clothing]), 천 턱받이(cloth bibs), 타이(ties), 가죽제 벨트(혁대-belts made of leather), 직물제 벨트(belts made out of cloth), 신발(footwear), 스카프(scarves), 의복용 장갑(gloves [clothing]), 등산용 장갑(climbing gloves), 사이클용 장갑(cycling gloves), 전자제품 터치기술을 가진 의복용 장갑(gloves for clothing having touch technology of electronic products), 스노우보드용 장갑(snowboarding gloves), 벙어리장갑(mittens), 헤드밴드(headbands), 손목밴드(의류-wristbands [clothing]), 머니벨트(의류-money belts [clothing]), 벨트(의복-belts [clothing]), 방한용 마스크(의류-winter face masks [clothing]), 폴로셔츠, 와이셔츠(dress shirts), 스포츠용 저지, 스포츠용 점퍼, 야구 유니폼, 운동용 바지, 반팔 또는 긴팔 티셔츠, 점퍼, 수영복(bathing suits), 반바지, 탱크탑, 방한용 장갑, 넥타이, 파자마, 스웨트팬츠, 스웨트셔츠, 속셔츠와 기저귀 커버가 달린 직물제 유아복(babies cloth clothing with undershirt and diaper cover

B. (1) On March 22, 2017, the examiner of the Korean Intellectual Property Office (hereinafter “Korea Intellectual Property Office”) indicated the Plaintiff with respect to the trademark “” of this case, and the trademark of this case is indicated in a common way the shape of both horses, and is used for both horses and clothing, etc. as designated goods, and thus, does not have distinctiveness because it directly indicates the goods or is merely an ordinary name.