1. The decision made by the Intellectual Property Tribunal on October 12, 2016 by the Intellectual Property Tribunal on the case shall be revoked.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be.

1. Basic facts

A. The Defendants initially filed a single application for the instant patent invention, and registered as F Patent, but registered as Defendant C with part of the patent right on March 5, 2015. Defendant C renounced its patent right on August 4, 2016, but was transferred part of the patent right from Defendant B again on November 1, 2016.

The title of the patented invention of this case (No. 2 and 3) 1: D2) filing date/registration date/registration number: E/F/G 3) claims (the corrected publication was made on October 19, 2015) 【 Claim 1】 【 Claim 1】 The lower part of the upper part of the first part of the first part of the first part is known to the lower part of the patent invention of this case, and the lower part of the said 1st part is known to the upper part of the said 1st part of the said 1st part of the said 1st part of the said 1st part of the patent invention (hereinafter referred to as “part 1”).

(ii) Being inserted in and fixed to the eromos inserted in the eromos (10) formed in the foregoing erosctic erosctic erosculs (9); the erosculic erosculic erosculs (12) formed by the upper part of the inside part of the erosculs; the erosculs (12) formed by the air through which the air is moved at regular intervals on the upper part of the erosculs (12); and the erosculs (11) filled in the upper part of the erosculs

(xi) Guboards (14) (hereinafter referred to as “entents 3”) that are assembled by bringing to upper upper part of the codives (9) of the indives of the indial morality (11) above;

(ii) Cases (i) in which a theft line (ii) is formed on the upper side and formed with an inner part (15) and air inflow (5) formed before and after both sides, with an inner part (4) formed, and with an inner part (3) formed by the opening and closing section (3) formed to assemble in parallel on the front side (hereinafter referred to as "concept 4").

(i) solid fuels in which solid fuels are inserted in the inside of the above cases (1) and in which solid fuels are stored (8) in a solid fuel receiving box (7) (hereinafter referred to as “entents 5”) in the central part;

(b) include the above-mentioned solid fuels (14).