1. The Defendant’s judgment against the Plaintiff on the Seoul Central District Court case was rendered on May 10, 2016.

In full view of the overall purport of the arguments in Gap 2 through 4, the defendant was sentenced to the judgment in Paragraph 1 of the Disposition against the plaintiff, the plaintiff was granted the exemption decision on September 7, 2018 in Incheon District Court 2018Da644 exemption decision, and the fact that the above decision became final and conclusive is recognized.

Although the defendant's claim was omitted in the list of creditors at that time, there is no evidence to deem that the plaintiff intentionally submitted false application documents, the above immunity decision also remains effective as to the defendant's claim.

Therefore, the plaintiff's claim seeking non-performance of compulsory execution based on the above judgment is accepted.