1. All of the plaintiffs' claims are dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the plaintiffs.

1. Determination as to the plaintiff A, etc.'s claim

A. Basic Facts 1) The status of the parties and the Defendant Company for the Plaintiff, etc. is a corporation operating insurance business, etc., and the Plaintiff, etc., as the employees of the Defendant Company, was dismissed on January 31, 2005 from the Defendant Company (hereinafter “instant layoff”).

3) The Defendant Company is a trade union member of the Korea Life Insurance Industry Trade Union (hereinafter referred to as the “Trade Union Branch”) comprised of 480 members.

(2) The net income of the Defendant Company (No. 47) from April 1, 2003 to March 31, 2004 under the income statement of the Defendant Company (No. 53,389,512,604 won, but the net income of April 1, 2004 to March 31, 2005 (No. 48) was reduced by 26,327,982,79 won compared to that of electricity. Separately, in 203, 2004, 731,374, 90, 390, 390, 365, 205, 206, 365, 206, 205, 365, 206, 365, 206, 205, 206, 365, 206, 296, 206, 365, 297, 296, 36

(unit: c) The total assets, capital performance, the number of stores, and the designer as of August 2004 of another insurance company (new life, E.S. life, E.N.) whose size of assets with the defendant company is similar to that of the defendant company are as follows (the sales are as of 2003:

A. Unit: The amount of KRW 44,324 2,124 2,124 15,889 218 765 6,377 26,802 1,533 16,580 663,496 263,853 680 15,95 119,95 119 1,024 42,572,3422,678 2,678 83 4,833 divided, 6,377 16, 201 201 202 1,024,971 42,572,3422,678 2,512 4,833 divided,83 199, 200 16,584,968 206,985