Text
1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.
2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.
Reasons
1. Basic facts
A. The Plaintiff is a corporation that operates a wood manufacturing business and sales business, and the Defendant is a corporation that operates a housing construction business and sales business.
B. The Defendant is an executor of each joint housing construction project in a district A 51,52 block and B zone A3 block (hereinafter referred to as “A zone” and “B zone”). On December 2, 2013, the construction work of interior 51 block in a district A zone A, and the construction work of interior 51 block in a zone B zone B on April 2, 2014 (hereinafter referred to as “each of the instant subcontract”).
The main contents of each subcontract of this case are as follows.
(A)
1. The project owner: A district 51,52 block;
2. The name of subcontracted project: 51 block wooden project;
4. Period of a contract for a construction project: The contract amount: 2,934,801,90 won on August 31, 2015, as of December 2, 2013, when the construction project commences;
(a) Value of supply: Labor cost under Article 84 of the Enforcement Decree of the Framework Act on the Construction Industry of 979,169,200 won, among the value of supply of 2,93,827,420 won;
(b) Value-added tax: 974,480 won;
8. Contract bond: 293,480,190 won; 10. Liability period: Three years after completion (B district);
1. The project owner: A district A3 block;
2. The name of the subcontracted project: Domestic wooden project;
4. Period of a construction contract: Contract amount on May 31, 2015, the date of completion of April 2, 2014,: 3,660,000,000 won (the change to KRW 3,660,000,000 on May 12, 2014);
(a) The value of supply: Labor cost out of the value of supply 3,659,342,779 won (the change of the value to 3,636,472,124 won on May 12, 2014): Labor cost under Article 84 of the Enforcement Decree of the Framework Act on the Construction Industry of 979,169,200 won;
(b) Value-added tax: 657,221 won (the change of KRW 652,876 on May 12, 2014);
8. Contract bond: 366,00,000 won; Liability period for warranty: Common details of each of the subcontract in this case for five years after completion;
9. The rate of warranty bond: 10% of the contract amount; 11. The rate of liquidated damages: The general terms and conditions of the subcontract of construction works, which are part of the subcontract of this case, shall be 0.3% of the contract amount per day immediately: Provided, That the zone B shall be