1. Of the part against the plaintiffs in the judgment of the court of first instance, the part against the plaintiffs who are ordered to pay below.

Basic Facts

The election of the Chairperson of the F Trade Union(hereinafter referred to as the "FEU") is multiple labor unions by company H affiliated with the GEU.

A, who was a co-defendant of the first instance court, is a member of the FF Trade Union, for the same month as August 6, 2014.

7. A person who was selected as a candidate for the election of the Chairperson of the FMMMF.

Plaintiff

B is F employee, and Plaintiff C is a member of the G Trade Union.

On the other hand, Defendant D is the head of the FF labor union I branch, and Defendant E is the head of the FF labor union J branch.

The term of office of the first executive officer of the F labor union shall expire on August 6, 2014 and the same month as August 6, 2014.

7. The election of the Chairperson of the FMA was held, and K of the B and the predecessor.

In the above election, A obtained more than K 10 votes, but “in the event that there are two candidates, if there is no one who has obtained the majority, he/she shall make a provisional vote to one person who has obtained the majority votes and determine the election at the time of a majority of the votes” was decided to proceed on August 12, 2014 in accordance with the union election management regulations.

On August 11, 2014, the Defendants sent the e-mail of the Defendants and the Internet bulletin board of the Foon Line A (hereinafter referred to as the “instant bulletin board”) posted a notice stating that “C, A, B, etc. were affiliated with a L organization, the core strike of the O political party. L organization, which is an organization, should not be allowed to search L organization C, A, and B at the Internet search book.”

In addition, if the name of "L organization C or A" was searched under the title of " what is the parliamentary body," a notice was posted in the title of "O Political Party Dobong-gu - 4050 new departures", which includes a closure screen that the name of " C or A is searched."

A on August 11, 2014, 17:29, the article linked to the result of the search on the bulletin board of this case is not a list of L organizations, but a list of 5,300 workers who signed against the branch of the O party.

Actual articles shall be deducted.