1. The request for intervention by an independent party intervenor shall be rejected;

2. The Plaintiff’s claim against the Defendants is dismissed in entirety.

1. The following facts may be acknowledged in light of the purport of the whole pleadings in each statement of evidence Nos. 1 through 5, 7, Eul evidence Nos. 1, 2, 4-1, Byung evidence No. 1, 1, 2, 3, and 6.

The Plaintiff’s status as the parties is a company with the purpose of safety diagnosis and inspection of civil engineering construction facilities, structure design, repair and reinforcement business, etc. The purpose of the Defendant Law Firm is the attorney-at-law’s duties. Defendant A is the attorney-at-law who is a member of the Defendant Law Firm, and the intervenor is the council of occupants’ representatives comprised of the occupants for the management of Pyeongtaek-si C Apartment (13 Dongdong, 862 Dong, hereinafter “instant apartment”).

B. On September 9, 2008, the intervenor received the contents of the defect diagnosis service of the apartment of this case from 6 facilities defects diagnosis companies including the plaintiff, and the service cost proposed by the plaintiff was 16,000,000 won. The service cost proposed by the other company was 10,000,000 won or 17,50,000 won. 2) After that, around October 9, 2008, the intervenor received from the plaintiff a proposal for the defect diagnosis service and the cost of the apartment of this case on the premise that the lawsuit for damages was filed against the plaintiff due to the defect of the apartment of this case was filed by the plaintiff, and the intervenor stated that the damages claim amount was 10,000,000 won, but the proposal was stated below.

6. Estimated estimate proposal (Separate Amount of Value-Added Tax): 1. In case of false inspection of defects (the case of separate contract for attorney-at-law's affairs): 16,00,000 won for down payment (50% payment at the time of the contract, 50% payment at the time of submission of the report) and 10% of royalties at the time of the completion of the business (the termination of the contract or the settlement of the lawsuit) (2) In case of false inspection of defects (the case of a contract including attorney-at-law's affairs): 12% of the down payment (the time of payment by the attorney-at-law) and the down