1. The Defendant: 17,696,970 won, Plaintiff B, D, and E respectively; 2,949,495 won, and Plaintiff C.

1. Basic facts

A. On October 1948, when the occurrence of a civilian sacrifice incident by the police police in the Mineyang area, from around October 1948 to around January 1, 1951 during the Korean War period, the Mineyang Police Station and soldiers belonging to the 15th Armed Forces of the Republic of Korea who jointly and severally cooperated with the residents of the above area for the prompt mountain and decentralization (hereinafter referred to as “the civilian sacrifice case by the police police in the Mineyang area”) was suspected of being killed or was killed in a group on the ground that they were the family members of the soldiers.

B. On May 31, 2005, the previous Settlement Commission established pursuant to the Framework Act on the Settlement of History for Truth established by Act No. 7542 (hereinafter “The Act on the Settlement of History”) for the Reconciliation of Truth (hereinafter “The Commission for Settlement of History”) decided to ascertain the truth during the period of application for the verification of truth (from December 1, 2005 to November 30, 2006) during which the military police filed an application for the case of civilian damage that occurred in the process of punishing anti-Gun during the period of Korean War after the Korean War, and conducted an investigation, and on May 11, 2010, the Commission determined to ascertain the truth that residents were 66 persons were sworn.

(2) On January 14, 1951, the court below found that the Defendant J (the birth in January 1931) was guilty, and found that the Defendant J (J, South, 19 years old), L, and M passed a concurrent examination in the Mineyang Police Station on January 15, 1951, and that the Defendant was guilty of the charge and was led to the police and was killed in the night area near the village of the Simsan City, and determined the “verification” as a result of the confirmation of sacrifice.

C. Family relationship 1 of victims is the victim J (hereinafter “the deceased”) recognized in the decision of the Committee on the Settlement of History

around January 15, 1951, which is the time of death of the deceased, the father N, O, o.