1. The decision of the first instance court is modified following the changes in the plaintiffs' claims in the trial.

The plaintiffs.

1. Basic facts

A. On February 3, 2001, the RA clubs organized the Council of Members and established Defendant F Co., Ltd. by 3,106.

B. On November 15, 2001, the Defendant: (a) opened a R consortium on February 10, 2002 (hereinafter “instant golf club”); and (b) opened the H consortium on February 10, 2002; and (c) allowed those who wish to enter the instant golf club among the sports assistants who had access to the instant golf club, to enter the said club as the Defendant’s sports assistant.

Plaintiff

From around 194, Plaintiff C from around 1995, Plaintiff Q from around May 201, and Plaintiff Q from around May 2001, entered the instant golf course as the Defendant’s game assistant from February 10, 2002.

C. On June 9, 2003, some sports assistants of the instant golf course, including I, constituted the K-Subdivision of the JAC (hereinafter “instant trade union”). D.

From June 12, 2003 to the 14th day of the same month, the defendant publicly announced that Gyeonggi assistants will select sports-related workers (not only general employees, but also sports assistants will work to support the selection of sports-related workers, and ordinary world workers will work as sports-related workers) and then submitted L on June 17, 2003 when submitting L's job application form among sports-related assistants, L will be newly employed as a food-related sports and S as of June 18, 2003, and L will play a role as L's master (the direction and supervision of sports assistants under the direction of the Games).

마. 이에 “피고가 이 사건 노동조합을 와해시키기 위하여 허위로 경기진행요원을 선발한다는 공고를 하여 다른 경기보조원들로 하여금 지원하지 않도록 한 후 입사지원서를 제출한 L를 캐디 마스터로 채용함으로써 경기보조원 중 신망이 두터운 자를 캐디 마스터로 선발하는 관례를 깼다”는 비난여론이 경기보조원들...