1. The plaintiff's appeal is all dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

Purport of claim and appeal

The first instance court.

1. Facts of recognition;

A. On the Internet site world clubs (htp:/www.sdayb.com) provide three clubs music broadcasting services that enable the subscribers to open a broadcasting station on an online basis and play music broadcasts. Defendant B operates “H” using the above services on its members ID (e.g., separate names) and Defendant C’s member IDF (Ga: G). In addition, the above website provides the subscribers with automatic creation of an Internet space, such as the user’s personal homepage.

B. H operated by the Defendants is operated in the form of a protocol, and the operator of a club is authorized to establish and manage the broadcasting channel of a personal broadcasting station, to operate a bulletin board, or to decide to allow a person to use a message to a certain extent, and to close the protocol itself.

다. 원고는 I 6:00경 위 H의 자유게시판에 “J”라는 제목의 글을 게시하였고, 위 게시물에, 피고 B은 “다 읽기에 참으로 긴 내용이군요. 당일까지만 게시한 후 삭제하겠다”라는 내용의 댓글을 달았고, 피고 C는 “내가 아침부터 이 글 보고 짧지도 않은 긴 글을 보고 토할 뻔했음 좋은 글도 다 못 보는데 이런 글을 왜 봐야는지 제발 쫌 생각 좀하고 삽시다!!! K 19:28 이 글은요 이 글은요 잠시 후 제가 삭제하겠습니다”라는 내용의 댓글을 달았다. 라.

Defendant C deleted the above post around 19:30.

[Ground of recognition] Facts without dispute, Gap evidence Nos. 1 and 2, the purport of the whole pleadings

2. The deletion of the above article posted by the Plaintiff in the above H is unlawful as an act infringing the Plaintiff’s freedom of expression, and Defendant B bears the responsibility to manage the above bulletin board, and Defendant C is jointly and severally liable to compensate for mental damages suffered by the Plaintiff.