1. The decision made by the Intellectual Property Tribunal on November 23, 2016 on a case No. 2015 won70 shall be revoked.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be.

1. Basic facts

(a) The filing date and the application number of the trademark in this case (Evidence 1) 1: B/ C2: 3) Designated goods classified as Category 3: Cosmetics classified as the category of goods, cosmetics, cosmetics, cosmetics, cosmetics, sludges, Edibines, ship-to-bes, beer, beer-day, beer-beer for cremation, beer-beer for cremation, shampoos and uniforms, shampoos, shamper for children, cosmetics for human body, shampers, social shampers for children, shampers, water shampers, hydrogens, sprinkers, sprinks, sprinks, sprinks 4): The applicant: the Plaintiff

나. 선등록상표 1) 선등록상표 1 (갑 제5호증) 가) 출원일/ 등록일/ 등록번호: 2011. 1. 31./ 2012. 4. 5./ 제0914213호 나) 구성: 다) 지정상품: 상품류 구분 제3류의 바디크림, 베이비 파우더, 스킨케어용 화장품 외 별지와 같다. 라) 등록권리자: 주식회사 아모레퍼시픽 2) 선등록상표 2 (갑 제6호증) 가) 출원일/ 등록일/ 갱신등록일/ 소멸일/ 등록번호: 1994. 9. 6./ 1995. 11. 10./ 2005. 9. 13./ 2015. 11. 11./ 제0326115호 나) 구성: 다) 지정상품: 상품류 구분 제3류의 일반화장수, 스킨로션, 탤컴파우더, 헤어컨디셔너, 화장용 욕용염, 쉐이빙겔, 향주머니, 실내향용 스프레이, 향단지 라) 등록권리자: 크랩트리 앤드 에버린 홀딩즈 리미티드

C. On November 16, 2015, the examiner of the Korean Intellectual Property Office rendered a decision to refuse the registration of the applied trademark of this case on the ground that “The trademark of this case is identical or similar to the prior registered trademark 1, 2, and the names and concepts of the essential parts of the trademark, and thus there is a concern for general consumers to mislead or confuse the source, and thus it is not possible to obtain trademark registration as it falls under Article 7(1)7 of the former Trademark Act (wholly amended by Act No. 1403, Feb. 29, 2016; hereinafter the same shall apply).” On December 17, 2015, the Plaintiff filed a petition for a trial seeking revocation of the said decision of refusal (2015 won7470) with the Korean Intellectual Property Tribunal, and the Korean Intellectual Property Tribunal on November 23, 2016.”