1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

1. Basic facts

A. The name of the device of this case (A No. 1) 1: C2) filing date/registration date/B/B 3: The owner of the utility model right: Defendant 4) claims 【 Claim 1】 Claim 】 After-hander who combines the front side of the mobile phone (hereinafter “Composition 1”; “Composition 2”; hereinafter “Composition 3”; hereinafter “Composition 3”; hereinafter the aforementioned combination means which combines the aforesaid front part of the mobile phone with the aforesaid front part of the mobile phone (hereinafter “Composition 3”); hereinafter the foregoing combination means are made including extension connected by extending the above front line to the front lineer’s side (hereinafter “Composition 4”; hereinafter the above combinations are linked to the front line (hereinafter “Composition 5); hereinafter the above combinations with the front line and the front line (hereinafter “the front line”) which are formed within the front line of the next lineer’s day; hereinafter the above combinations with the front line and the front line (hereinafter “the front line”) which are composed of the two separate cell lines and the front line (hereinafter “the front”).

B. 1) On February 8, 2011, the comparison design 1 (No. 4) concerns the 's covered opening structure of a cellphone case' published by the disclosure number No. 20-201-001200 in the Utility Model Gazette published on February 8, 2011, and its main contents and drawings are as shown in attached Form 2. 2) The comparison design 2 (No. 5) is merely a photograph of a specific product of the comparison design 2 (No. 5) but it is called the 'presure' for the convenience of comparison.

The term “a design” refers to both a design or an invention, the subject of comparison is not an actual device, and the same purport is called “a design.”

On February 23, 2012, the Internet blousesian’s “gallon block block scenario” photographed on the Internet Blouseg, and the main contents and photographs thereof are as shown in attached Form 3.

3) A portable device with a structure 3 (A. 6 No. 20-207-00111, published in the Utility Model Gazette as of October 19, 2007) compared to the comparison subject matter 3 (A. 6 No. 2007).