1. The plaintiffs' appeal is dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal are assessed against the Plaintiffs.

The purport of the claim and appeal is the purport of the appeal.

1. Basic facts

A. The parties’ relationship 1) D Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “D”).

) E (hereinafter “instant golf course”) is a golf course located in Dong-gu, Nam-gu, Chungcheongnam-gu. G.

(1) The corporation is a company operating the corporation and H (hereinafter “H”)

(2) The Defendant is an audit of D and H and the spouse of I, a shareholder of H, who owns 100% of D’s shares.

3) The Plaintiffs are creditors returning membership fees of the instant golf course membership. (B) On July 31, 2013, J purchased KRW 619,620,00 from D’s 52 cart and other movables in the corporeal movables auction procedure. On August 23, 2013, the Defendant purchased KRW 80,000 from J as 52 cart and other movables from J on August 23, 2013.

2) On August 2013, the Defendant and D shall enter into a contract for the transfer of business rights (Evidence No. 28-24, hereinafter “instant contract for the transfer of business rights”) with the content that the Defendant received from D the goodwill from D for the use of the cart and the COS equipment of the instant golf course.

A) According to the instant business transfer agreement, the contract term is ten years, and the contract term is automatically renewed on a five-year basis if the parties do not express their intent to terminate the contract within three months after the contract expires, and the Defendant shall pay 30% of the sales amount of the total car fee paid by the golf course users in return for running the cart business to D. Meanwhile, the Defendant and D shall lease the 52 cart and the 13 cart equipment, etc. to D, and D shall, in return, pay D the full amount of the cart usage fee (including value added tax) to the Defendant, and D shall pay D the sales amount (including 20% of the total sales amount) to D out of the 65 cart total amount to the Defendant every six months. The contract term is ten years, and the contract term is automatically renewed on an five-year basis if the parties do not express their intent to terminate the contract within three months after the contract expires, and the date of preparation shall be “A. 28, 2013.”