The defendant shall be innocent.

1. No person who outlines the facts charged shall drink alcoholic beverages with customers, provide entertainment services to customers by singing or dancing, or arrange other persons to provide such services at a place where food entertainment is conducted for profit;

Nevertheless, around September 26, 2015, the Defendant assisted three persons, who are in the Gangseo-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government D and the second floor, supplied to customers F, etc. by the news agency H, the main business operator of the news agency “G”, to engage in entertainment with customers, by having three persons, who drink with the news agency, drink with the customer, and encourage them to provide entertainment by singing and dancing.

2. Determination

A. The facts charged in a criminal trial must be proved by the prosecutor, and the judge should be convicted with evidence having probative value, which leads to the conviction that the facts charged are true beyond a reasonable doubt. Therefore, if there is no such evidence, even if there is a suspicion of guilt against the defendant, it shall be determined with the benefit of the defendant.

B. According to the evidence duly adopted and investigated by this court, F and I went to the instant dan on September 22, 2015, and thereafter, J met with F and I’s recommendation, and F, etc.: (a) drink and singing together with three female women; (b) on the day of the instant case from 23:16 to 23:28, the call was made between H, which operates the instant Garan broker, with the trade name of the instant Garan and “G”; (c) H had arranged the instant Ga, at the request of the instant Garan; and (d) it is recognized that J made a written statement with three Ga in the police at the time of the instant case.

However, the following circumstances acknowledged by the foregoing evidence, i.e., the instant case, where F et al. had a dispute with K employees due to the calculation of expenses in the instant dan around September 00, 2015.