The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

Litigation costs shall be borne by the plaintiff.

1. Basic facts

A. The title of the instant patent invention 1: C2) filing date/registration date//registration number: D/E/F3: patentee: G, H, I, and J4): Claims 5 (Korean Intellectual Property Tribunal’s corrective decision on July 12, 2018, published on August 9, 2018), 13 (hereinafter “instant Claim 13”) claims 13 (hereinafter “instant Claim 13”).

(1) In the process in which a certified booker receives subscription information from the end of customer movement to the issuing member of an electronic receipt containing the card number or telephone number personal identification information (Composition 1); the process in which such certified booker creates the personal identification code or QR code at the end of customer movement (Composition 2); when a customer purchases a product or is provided with a service through a franchise store, he/she shall, along with the settlement information at the end of the franchise store, read the code or QR code at the end of the customer movement and transmit it to the settlement server and request the settlement approval (Composition 3-1); the above certified booker shall, upon completion of the settlement of the end of the franchise store from the settlement server, verify the electronic identification code at the end of the customer movement or QR code at the request of the issuing member of the electronic receipt; the process in which the former is requested to issue the electronic receipt (Composition 3-2); the above certified personal identification code at the time of the issuance of the personal identification code or QR code at the end of the franchise store; and shall transmit the identification number at the above to the customer license number at the end of the electronic receipt (Form).