1.(a)

The judgment of the court of first instance ordering the following payment among the plaintiffs' claims for damages against the defendants.

The Plaintiffs filed a claim for damages due to a tort against the Defendants and the Co-Defendant F Co-Defendant F Co., Ltd. of the first instance court (hereinafter “F”), and the first instance court accepted the Defendants’ claim and dismissed the F’s claim.

As to this, only the Defendants appealed against the part against the Defendants in excess of “49,00,000 won and the amount calculated at the rate of 5% per annum from the day following the delivery date of the copy of the instant complaint to the day of full payment. The Plaintiffs filed a claim for loans and the amount for settlement of accounts with Defendant C and D respectively, and the first instance court dismissed all of the conjunctive claims against Defendant C and D, and dismissed the conjunctive claim against Defendant C. Accordingly, the first instance court dismissed part of the conjunctive claim against Defendant C and dismissed the conjunctive claim against Defendant C. Accordingly, the Defendant appealed appealed against the part against the Defendant in excess of “12,464,487 won and the amount calculated at the rate of 5% per annum from the day following the delivery date of the copy of the instant complaint to the day of full payment.”

The scope of this Court's adjudication is limited to ① the part against the Defendants exceeding 49,00,000 won and delay damages for the damages against the Defendants, ② the part against the Defendant C, which exceeds 12,464,487 won and delay damages for the settlement of accounts against the Defendant C, and ② the part against the Defendant C, which exceeds the damages for delay.

Defendant E (hereinafter “Defendant E”) is a corporation established for the purpose of lending recruitment agency business, etc. of financial institutions.

Defendant D is the representative director of Defendant E, and Defendant C is the husband of Defendant D and is the actual operator of Defendant E.

Plaintiff

A transferred KRW 150 million in total to Defendant E’s account on April 19, 201, KRW 25 million on May 3, 2011, and KRW 150 million on June 3, 2011, to Defendant E’s account, and the aforementioned KRW 150 million on May 15, 201.