beta
Text
1. Of the judgment of the court of first instance, the part against the defendant shall be revoked, and all the plaintiffs' claims corresponding to the revoked part shall be revoked.
Reasons
1. Facts of recognition;
A. Plaintiff A (1) is the owner of the EYF Lasta car (hereinafter “Plaintiff A”), and the driver of FF vehicle insured by the Defendant’s comprehensive motor vehicle insurance policy, around 20:00 on May 17, 2013, Plaintiff A driven the Defendant’s vehicle on the side of the Defendant’s vehicle at the south-dong, Cheongdong-dong, Chungcheongnam-gu, Chungcheongnam-gu, Yandong-gu, Yandong-gu, Cheongsan-dong, and caused an accident that caused the Plaintiff A’s vehicle to shock the front part of the Plaintiff A vehicle while driving the vehicle on the side of the Defendant’s vehicle at a high-speed speed.
(2) After the accident of this case, the Plaintiff A was repaired by G in the automobile repair business chain, and the Defendant paid KRW 8,543,510 as insurance money.
(3) The main repair content of the Plaintiff A’s vehicle is the postwards due to the damage of the front and rear side of the body, the wheel chairss, the tamp chairss, the bridges, the white panels, and the ligrists, the exchange of each of the ligr, the ligr, the ligr, the freer, the ligr, the ligr, the ligr, the Largr, the Largr, the trigr, and the respective set of the trigral floor panel.
(4) On the other hand, the Plaintiff A’s vehicle was registered on November 16, 201 and passed one year and six months after the release of the instant accident at the time of the instant first accident, and approximately 34,500 km in odometer, and the vehicle’s height immediately before the instant first accident is KRW 24,550,000.
B. Plaintiff B (1) The Plaintiff B is the owner of HFFF vehicle (hereinafter “Plaintiff B”), and the driver of the IF vehicle insured by the Defendant’s comprehensive motor vehicle insurance caused an accident of shocking the Plaintiff B vehicle which was parked without permission while driving a vehicle on the Defendant’s side of Pyeongtaek-si on July 6, 2013, around 17:00.
(2) After the accident of this case, the plaintiff B was repaired from the car repair business chain Co., Ltd., and the defendant paid KRW 4,695,003 as insurance money.
(3) Plaintiff B’s vehicle.