1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

The details and details of the disposition are corporations that produce and sell high strength concrete files (PHC files) established around August 26, 2002. The Plaintiff is a corporation that produces and sells high strength concrete files (PHC files).

B The cooperative (hereinafter “the cooperative of this case”) is a non-profit corporation established with the main purpose of the development of the concrete industry and the promotion of the welfare of its members, among domestic small and medium enterprises producing a PHC file that reinforces the brick base around February 1990, the lower court-oriented concrete fume, which is sewage pipes, and power supply and distribution, and telecommunications concrete poles.

Plaintiff

The 17 companies [the plaintiffs, C Co., Ltd., D Co., Ltd., E Co., Ltd., F Co., Ltd., G Co., Ltd., H Co., Ltd., H Co., Ltd., J Co., Ltd., K Co., Ltd., Ltd., M Co., Ltd., M Co., Ltd., Ltd., P Co., Ltd., Q2 Co., Ltd., Ltd., Ltd., and stock-type Co., Ltd., Ltd., Ltd., and individual

[2] All members of the above association are members of the association.

On July 1, 2016, S, the representative director of the Plaintiff and the president of the instant association, in collusion with the executive officers of the instant association, the representative director of the instant association, or the person in charge of bidding affairs, etc. from July 1, 201 to May 24, 2016, as to the government-funded PHC file purchase bid among the instant association and the members of the instant association from July 2011 to May 24, 201, designated a successful bidder in advance (association or individual member companies) and designated a successful bidder in advance, and invested the price at a higher price than the pre-determined bid price, and the remaining company shall not intentionally be awarded a successful bidder in a way that does not participate in the relevant bid, nor shall the person awarding the contract be selected as a successful bidder in a way that publicly announced by the initial limited competition method so that the other company may not intentionally be selected as a successful bidder, a single bid, or a successful bidder exceeding the estimated price.