Text
1. Each of the plaintiffs' claims is dismissed.
2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the plaintiffs.
Reasons
1. Basic facts
A. On October 2014, the Plaintiffs and L (L also filed a lawsuit of this case with the original Plaintiffs, but withdrawn the lawsuit of this case) owned each of the 16 units of K house on the ground of Eunpyeong-gu Seoul Eunpyeong-gu Seoul J (hereinafter “instant land”) intended to implement a reconstruction project to remove K housing and newly build new 29 households’ multi-households on the site (hereinafter “K reconstruction project”).
B. Around May 2015, Defendant I proposed that he would proceed with the K reconstruction project to the sectional owners of the K Housing, and the Plaintiffs and L decided to re-occupant after the completion of the K reconstruction project, and the rest of nine generations’ sectional owners sold their rights and agreed to sell their rights.
At that time, the Plaintiffs, L, Defendant G (Defendant I’s wife), and Defendant H determined the share relationship by distributing the said nine generations’ rights as follows:
(1) Plaintiffs (six persons): 3/162 L: 3/16 (2) : (3) Defendant G: 6/16 (as sold to an existing household and obtained the rights of two households among nine households) (as part of nine households, six households among nine households) (4) Defendant H: 1/16 (as part of nine households sold and nine households, one household among nine households).
C. In order to raise funds for K reconstruction projects, the Plaintiffs and Defendant I obtained loans from L, Plaintiff C, Defendant G, and Defendant H 4 as representative borrowers on October 5, 2015 in total of KRW 1,920,000,000,000,000,000 from L, Plaintiff C, Defendant G, and Defendant H, respectively, under the name of the said four persons.
L prepares a prop-joint business contract (Evidence 5) with the content that L will carry on the business with the delegation of all the powers concerning K reconstruction project between the plaintiffs, the defendants, G and H, who are other equity right holders.
In addition, L is in the capacity of the representative promotion chairperson representing other equity right holders, and on November 12, 2015, the "Defendant I will be responsible for the financing for the K reconstruction project and the progress of the project, and some of the households will be supplied to the equity right holders after completion of the project.