1. Defendant (Appointed Party) A and Appointed E among the judgment of the first instance, including the Plaintiff’s claim extended at the trial.

Basic Facts

Under the National Health Insurance Act, the Plaintiff is a non-profit public-service corporation that manages and operates health insurance for the prevention, diagnosis, and rehabilitation of diseases and injuries, childbirth, death, health promotion, etc. of citizens, and F is the health insurance policyholder operated by the Plaintiff.

F is the victim of the following assault case (hereinafter referred to as “instant accident”), and the defendant A is the father E of the perpetrator of the instant accident, and the defendant C is the father of another perpetrator.

F, Selected E, and Defendant B all were students in the third grade of H Middle School located in Daejeon-gu Daejeon at the time of the instant accident.

On May 25, 2010, the designated parties E began to fighting with the Dara from Dara to F in the lower school on May 25, 2010, and the two underground parking lots were located between F and the designated parties E, and Defendant B, the residence of the designated parties E at around 15:40 on the same day, with the second underground parking lots located between the Daejeon Sung-gu I Apartment-gu 501 and 502.

At this point, the Appointor E assaulted F by taking the face of F one time with hand and the left part once, and the Appointor E’s provoking Defendant B assaulted F by taking the F’s bucks and side bucks once each time, on the ground that the fight was faced with the horse F, and the Selection E assaulted F by taking three times the face of the written F.

As a result, F suffered from injury such as cerebral cerebrovascular, cerebral cerebral cerebral cerebriforms less than 12 months which require medical treatment, ductal ductal ductal ductala, ductal ducta, incomplete ductal ducta,

From October 4, 2010 to March 27, 2015, F provided medical treatment at a medical care institution as the health insurance for the Plaintiff’s operation, as shown in the attached Table of Calculation of Damages. The total benefit cost is KRW 79,458,380. Of the costs, the Plaintiff paid KRW 57,636,030 (i.e., KRW 34,845,840, KRW 9,669,880, KRW 3208,910, KRW 7,424,60, KRW 1,801, KRW 930, KRW 684,870).

F and its families are Defendants A and C.