1. The plaintiff's claims against the defendants are all dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the plaintiff.

1. Basic facts

A. Status 1 of the parties concerned) The Plaintiff is a A apartment located in Seocho-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government D (hereinafter “instant apartment”).

(2) Defendant B served as the representative of the Plaintiff from May 10, 2014 to February 6, 2017, and Defendant C served as the head of the management office of the instant apartment for the said period.

B. The content of the instant management rules related to the instant apartment building management rules (hereinafter “instant management rules”) is as follows.

[Details of Management Rules of the apartment of this case] Article 26 (Matters to be Resolved by Council of Residents' Representatives)

9. Official commendation and award of the persons who have contributed to the management of collective housing. Article 33 (Operational Expenses) (2) The operation expenses of the council of occupants' representatives shall be composed of:

2. Allowances for attendance at meetings: 50,000 won per time (it shall not exceed 100,000 won per month).

3. Business promotion expenses for the president: 500,000 won per month.

6. Expenses incurred in purchasing surety insurance, etc. by the chairperson of the council of occupants' representatives under Article 69 (2);

7. Other operating expenses determined by the resolution of the council of occupants' representatives. (4) The council of occupants' representatives shall prepare details of use under the regulations on the use of operating expenses in a separate account book (including evidential materials) by the end of the following month, and the managing body shall disclose them to the

(5) Operating expenses shall be used for expenses for tea, beverage, transportation, communications, etc. and shall not be used for the purpose of amusement.

Article 60 (Execution of Miscellaneous Income and Disclosure of Accounting) (2) Any management entity may disburse Miscellaneous income preferentially as expenses necessary to revitalize the community and promote activities of residents' autonomy.

(3) The following matters, among the balance of execution after miscellaneous income is disbursed under paragraph (2), shall be accumulated as reserves for long-term repairs:

(4) The following contributions made by occupants and users to the accumulation of miscellaneous income in the balance of execution after miscellaneous income is disbursed pursuant to paragraph (2):