Text
1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.
2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.
Reasons
1. Basic facts
A. 1) The Plaintiff entered into a sales contract between the Plaintiff and C on April 9, 2003: (a) from C on April 9, 2003, the Plaintiff is only “D interest” (hereinafter “D interest”).
(2) E, E, 136 square meters, 20 square meters in F, 298 square meters in G, 298 square meters in G, 2,926 square meters in H, 521 square meters in G, 1,521 square meters in J, 1,782 square meters in each land (1 or 6 square meters in each land before the instant partition).
2) On May 12, 2003, the Changwon District Court (Seoul District Court 39609, and 39610 on May 12, 2003, the registration of ownership transfer in the Plaintiff’s name was completed.
나. 토지의 분할 2003. 9. 16. 위 ④ 토지는 ㉮ H 답 853㎡, ㉯ K 답 2,040㎡, ㉰ L 답 33㎡로, 위 ⑤ 토지는 ㉱ I 답 1,141㎡, ㉲ M 답 380㎡로, 위 ⑥ 토지는 ㉳ J 답 1,781㎡, ㉴ N 답 1㎡로 각 분할되었다.
다. 소유권이전등기의 경료 위 ① 내지 ③ 토지, ④의 ㉮ 토지, ⑤의 ㉱ 토지, ⑥의 ㉳ 토지[아래 마.2)항에서 보는 바와 같이, 위 ①, ②, ④의 ㉮ 토지, ⑤의 ㉱ 토지, ⑥의 ㉳ 토지는 모두 ④의 ㉮ 토지에 합병되어 별지 목록 제1항의 H 답 3,931㎡가 되었다.
아래에서는 합병 전 위 ① 내지 ③ 토지, ④의 ㉮ 토지, ⑤의 ㉱ 토지, ⑥의 ㉳ 토지나, 합병 후 H 답 3,931㎡와 별지 목록 제2항의 G 답 298㎡(위 ③토지)를 통칭할 경우 구별하지 아니하고 ‘이 사건 각 토지’라 한다
[2] On May 25, 2005, the Changwon District Court Kim Jong-hae registry office of the Republic of Korea (Law No. 51429, Apr. 25, 2005; hereinafter “each of the registrations in this case”) registered ownership transfer under the name of the defendant on the ground of sale on April 25, 20
(D) Each of the registrations of this case between the Plaintiff and the Defendant was completed based on the approval seal contract (hereinafter “instant approval seal contract”) stating that “the Plaintiff sells each of the lands of this case in KRW 29 billion to the Defendant on April 25, 2005” (hereinafter “instant approval seal contract”).
2. On the other hand, "the plaintiff on April 25, 2005, is the defendant 4.