Defendant

A Pronouncement of sentence shall be suspended for A.

Defendant

B shall be punished by a fine of 200,000 won.

Defendant

B above.

Punishment of the crime

No person shall provide a third party with personal information or receive such information without obtaining the consent of the subject of information.

Defendant

B is the electrical director of the management office that manages closed-circuit television images of the Goyang-gu, Busan Metropolitan City, and the defendant A is the auditor of the management office.

Defendant

A around June 2014, when there was a dispute over apartment management between the victim E, a resident of the above apartment, around the above management office around June 2014, on the ground that there was little room for the victim to reproduce a voice file in which the contents of the Defendant’s conversation related to the management of the apartment are recorded within the above management office, A demanded the Defendant B to provide a list of closed-circuit television images on which the victim heard the contents of the Defendant’s conversation, and the Defendant B printed the screen of the closed-circuit television screen containing the above pages to the Defendant A at the above time and place.

As a result, Defendant B provided a third party with the victim’s personal information without the victim’s consent, and Defendant A provided a video which is a personal information.

Summary of Evidence

1. Defendants’ partial statement

1. Legal statement of witness E;

1. The Defendants’ determination as to the Defendants’ assertion on the complaint chief and the police statement against E does not constitute personal information as prescribed by the Personal Information Protection Act, and the Defendants’ act constitutes a justifiable act that does not violate social rules. However, the personal information under the Personal Information Protection Act includes information that does not make it possible to identify a specific individual but can be easily combined with other information. Although the above screen is marked back by the victim, it is easily combined with other information, such as uniforms, etc.