1. The plaintiff's claims against the defendants are all dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

1. Basic facts

A. (1) On February 5, 2012, Nonparty C driven a D Private Taxi (hereinafter “Ma1”) around 06:45, and was driving at a three-lane point 323.4 km in the south-gu, west-gu, Yanananandong-gu, Seoul, at the time of the receipt of the Yanananandong-gu, along the three-lane, followed the rear edge of the E-vehicle owned by Defendant A (hereinafter “Ma2”) (hereinafter “Ma2”).

(hereinafter referred to as “the primary accident”). The vehicles Ma1 caused to the above primary accident to stop on the right side of the road, and Ma2 vehicles stopped in the reverse direction on the two-lanes.

(2) After 6-7 minutes from the time of the occurrence of the first accident, Nonparty F driven G Freight Truck (hereinafter “Ma3”) and proceeded into two-lanes, Nonparty F, who was stopped due to the previous accident, shocked the front of Ma2 vehicle.

(hereinafter referred to as “the second accident”). The second accident in the above second accident is the first vehicle, and the Ma3 vehicle was stopped in the direction of 9 cc from the first to the third vehicle.

(3) After a few minutes of the accident at the time of the accident, Nonparty H driven an I vehicle (hereinafter referred to as “Ma4 vehicle”) and proceeded in three lanes, Nonparty H shocked the left-hand part of the Ma3 vehicle loaded on the vehicle, which was stopped over three lanes from the first vehicle to the third vehicle.

The third accident is called ‘the third accident'.

(4) The specific circumstances of each of the above accidents are as shown in the table below, and the particulars of the accident-related persons are as follows. The owner of the vehicle number type car, the insurance company, Cmerzz and the Marine Insurance Mesz and Mesz Mesky Mesky Mesky Mesky Mesky Mesky, Defendant A, B Mesky Mesky Mesky Mesky Mesky Mesky Mesky Meskyp F. H (Mesky Me), J. Mesky Mesk

B. (1) The Plaintiff is an insurer who entered into a comprehensive automobile insurance contract with the non-party 2, with respect to the Ma-3 vehicle, and the insured non-party 2 accident and the third accident.