1. The Plaintiff:

A. Defendant B and C are jointly and severally liable for KRW 12,906,612 and KRW 6,160,855 among them.

1. Determination as to each claim against Defendant B, C, and D

A. Defendant B and C were entrusted with the duties of attracting customers related to the opening of a mobile phone by the Plaintiff, which is an agent of El branchus, around September 8, 2012 under the above consignment contract. On the other hand, around September 8, 2012, Defendant B and C agreed to pay the remaining installments for the existing mobile phone and the amount of 22,906,612 won each month to customers G, etc., and did not pay the above amount of 22,906,612 won each month. Accordingly, the Plaintiff incurred damages from the above large-scale payment of EL branchus Co., Ltd. from 22,906,612 to 205, 206, 160, 206, 160, 206, 160, 206, 206, 205, 206, 206, 1606, 206, 206, 206, 2016, 20606, 206.

As a result, the Plaintiff sustained damages equivalent to the amount of KRW 27,047,882 paid by the Plaintiff to ELS Co., Ltd., and the Plaintiff paid KRW 21,081,669 out of the amount equivalent to the said amount paid by the Plaintiff by July 15, 2015.

Therefore, Defendant C and D are jointly and severally liable for damages to the Plaintiff and they are more than KRW 27,047,882.