1. The Defendants jointly committed against the Plaintiff in relation to KRW 2,414,269,320 and Ghana from August 1, 2012 to Defendant A.

Facts of recognition

(1) The Plaintiff is a non-profit special corporation that performs duties prescribed by the National Health Insurance Act, such as the imposition and collection of insurance premiums, collection of collection of insurance premiums, management of insurance benefits, and payment of insurance benefit costs, pursuant to the National Health Insurance Act. (2) Defendant A is the chief director of the D Medical Life Cooperatives (hereinafter “D”) which is a non-profit corporation, and Defendant B is a director of D&D, and Defendant C is a person who operated the F Hospital in Gyeonggi-si E.

(1) The Defendants, other than medical personnel, are not medical personnel, F Hospital (hereinafter referred to as “F Hospital”) which is a medical institution by lending Defendant C in the name of Dves Consultation.

(2) The F Hospital was operated from January 10, 201 to March 2012 on a monthly basis under the name of deposit KRW 30,000,00,000 in return for the establishment and operation of the hospital, and as a reward for the use of its name. (3) The F Hospital was operated from January 10, 201 to March 201, and the Plaintiff claimed medical care benefits from the Plaintiff during the same period and received medical care benefits from the Plaintiff during the same period, and thereafter, the medical care benefits determined to be recovered by the Plaintiff around March 24, 2015 are KRW 2,414,269,320.

A final conviction 1) The Defendants were guilty of violation of the Medical Service Act that they established a medical institution under the name of “F Hospital” after employing a doctor and employees despite the absence of a doctor, etc., and (2) the Defendants conspired to operate the F Hospital from January 10, 201 to March 2012; and (3) requested the Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service to submit a statement of health care benefit to review the statement of health care benefit to the Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service, and obtained a total of KRW 2,417,178,70 for about 15 months from the Plaintiff who believed to be true, and acquired the said statement from the Plaintiff under the name of health care benefit expense (the charges of fraud, etc. were indicted, and the above court found the Defendants guilty of the above charges, etc., and Defendant A’s imprisonment with prison labor for 2 years and 6, and Defendant B.