1. Of the judgment of the court of first instance, the part against the defendant A among the judgment of the court of first instance regarding the defendant D is modified as follows.

Defendant D is against Plaintiff A.

1. Basic facts

A. Defendant Korea’s comprehensive is a company that executes the construction of H apartment (hereinafter “instant construction”) in Gyeongsan-si.

Construction period: Amount on March 10, 2015, completion of August 15, 2015: 1.3 billion won: Materials and items of "B" total floor space of 1.3 billion won: 85 billion won (including bend, balcony, PT floor, rooftop, and rooftop rail): Materials and expendable materials all together.

equipment, etc. includes equipment, etc.

Other matters shall be referred to as the special agreement: Settlement shall be made once a month, 50% of the construction process.

Special terms and conditions of the special agreement on construction works in the mold: The settlement shall be made once a month.

B. On March 8, 2015, Defendant 1: (a) contracted part of the instant construction project with Defendant D as a managing director to Defendant I Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “I”); (b) the part of the instant construction project involving molds, steel bars, rains, and concrete construction; and (c) the main part of the content thereof is as follows.

(2) The construction contract of this case was signed and sealed by Defendant D as joint and several surety in the contract of this case, on the other hand, since Defendant D did not cause his seal impression and seal impression at the time of entering into the construction contract of this case. Thus, the subcontractor of the construction contract of this case was a public column, and Defendant D signed and sealed the contract of this case as joint and several surety.

C. Plaintiff C&C supplied construction materials at the construction site of this case. Plaintiff A supplied construction materials at the construction site of this case, Plaintiff B supplied construction materials at the construction site of this case. Plaintiff C supplied construction materials at the construction site of this case. Plaintiff C engaged in C& work at the construction site of this case.

The Plaintiffs supplied the goods at the construction site of this case or performed construction work, and the Defendants’ refusal to pay the goods, thereby resulting in the Defendants’ refusal to pay KRW 20,752,655, and KRW 41,700,000.