1. On January 16, 2013, the above court with respect to the Daejeon District Court's 2008 Seosan District Court's 2008 Book1 shipowner, etc.

Ⅰ. Basic facts

1. Occurrence of an accident;

A. On December 7, 2007, the main tugboat "T (T)-5" and the auxiliary tugboat "T (T) T-3" were towed by the "T-1,828 tons C-1" of Samsung Heavy Industries Co., Ltd. and were sailing to the "Tsung Heavy Industries Shipbuilding" at the Incheon port, while the towing line of "Tsung 1" was cut down, the towing line of "Tsung 1" was 6:00,06, 6:00 southwest-west, Taenam-gun, Taenam-gun, Taenam-gun, Taenam-gun, Chungcheongnam-do, 126∑ 03' 10,00,000, 126° 03' 10,000,000, 146,848 tons of the cargo tanker "T-1,000,000, 30,000,000 tons of the oil tanker and 10,000 tons of the oil tanker (T-1,0, etc.).

(hereinafter “instant accident”). (b)

On December 10, 2007, the 4th day after the accident occurred, the outflow oil was pushed down around 15 hours due to a strong impact of the wind of Northwest, and was pushed down on the coast of Chungcheongnam-gun, Chungcheongnam-gun, west-gun, the southwest-do, the coast of the accident. On December 10, 2007, the 4th day after the accident occurred, the 70km length from the west-gun, Taean-gun, Taean-gun, the west-gun, the coast of the accident, to the west-gun, the west-gun, the west-gun, the coast of the accident, and the 70km length length from the west-gun, the west-gun, the west-gun, the west-gun, the west-gun, the coast of the coast of the coast,

C. Since December 10, 2007, the outflow oil came to go through and flow into the inland coast and the outer sea due to the influence of tidal currents, and came to remain under the influence of the wind of the North Korean wind, the nineth day after the accident occurred, from December 15, 2007, to the front sea of the Jeonnam-gun, the 11th day after December 17, 2007, to the front sea of the Sinsan-si, and the 31th day after January 6, 2008, to the coast of Chocheon-do, Jeju-do, Jeju-do, respectively.

2. Status of the parties

A. The plaintiff Hubee Liber.