1. Of the judgment of the court of first instance, the part against Defendant B, equivalent to the amount ordered under paragraph (2).

1. Basic facts

A. The NAV carpet “F” (hereinafter “the instant car page”) is the Internet car page created by 20 people who support G camping teams to view and support G camping-gu games together.

The Defendants are the operating staff of the instant car page as of July 2018, and the Plaintiff is a person who had served as the operating staff of the instant car page by February 2, 2018 and became a general member thereafter.

B. Around May 16, 2018, Defendant B posted a notice of additional recruitment of the instant carpet on the Kapet bulletin board.

On June 7, 2018, the Plaintiff posted a notice to the effect that “Defendant C is not suitable for the operating personnel due to personality problems, such as failing to comply with the personal commitments,” and a considerable number of the currently operating personnel should be replaced in the middle, due to lack of activities.”

C. Defendant B, one of the following day, insultingd the Plaintiff by using the expressions such as “Modra”, “Madra”, “Madra”, and “Madra” with respect to the Plaintiff at the Kafing room participating in the instant carpet on the same day.

Since then, when this fact became known to the Plaintiff, the Defendant B knew the Plaintiff on June 12, 2018.

After voting with members, Defendant C was elected as new operating staff around June 15, 2018.

E. On July 1, 2018, the Defendants held the instant carpet conference and followed the other party’s behavior or atmosphere on the carpet bulletin board, and forced withdrawal from the office once a warning is given once again, and forced withdrawal from the office without a warning if they determine that the operating team is serious, and immediately withdraw from the office without a warning, as there are other carpets within the carpets, as there are other carpets without participating in the carpet activities within the country.

All of the City Members.