1. All of the plaintiffs' claims are dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the plaintiffs.

Details of the disposition

The Plaintiffs refer to the structures that are maintained in a stable form against the underwater by organizing the roof, such as the crocfed rectangular materials to avoid the sunlight, snow, rain, etc. of the dead structure, and by giving the initial string power and giving the lectures.

is a small and medium enterprise that engages in designing and manufacturing business.

Around December 2014, the Defendant publicly announced a bid for the purchase of the procurement commodities for the dead structure (a contract with multiple suppliers). The main contents of the bid are as follows: “Name: dead structure, detailed description: 10,000 square meters of dead structure, capacity to be purchased, and estimated price: 5,000,000 won in accordance with a contract with multiple suppliers (excluding value-added tax): the counter-party shall be selected according to the contract with multiple suppliers; however, the eligibility for the application for the purchase shall be limited to the manufacturer registered to participate in the bid with ten detailed number (3023170101) in accordance with the National Comprehensive Electronic Procurement System Registration Regulations.”

On December 30, 2015, the details of the designation of products subject to direct purchase of competing products and construction materials among small and medium business operators, publicly notified by the Administrator of the Small and Medium Business Administration on the Small and Medium Business Administration, as of January 1, 2016, were implemented since January 1, 2016, a dead structure (the name of the three parts: PEF dead structure, PVF dead structure, PTPP dead structure, and other dead structure) was designated as a competing product for small and medium business proprietors (hereinafter “competitive products”).

On January 2016, when a dead structure was designated as competing products as above, the Defendant issued a corrective notice of bid for the procurement commodities (multi-supplier contract) around January 201, and the main contents thereof are as follows: The name of a dead structure, detailed product: PVF dead structure, PVF dead structure, PTS structure, PTS dead structure, and other dead structure: 10,000 square meters for each dead structure, and estimated price: 5,00,000,000 won for estimated price (excluding value-added tax): The contracting party shall be selected according to the contract with multiple suppliers; the eligibility for the application for the purchase shall be 3023170101, 3023170101, PVF dead structure: 30230102, 30231703, 30103, and other structures:103, and other structures.