A defendant shall be punished by imprisonment for four months.

However, the execution of the above punishment shall be suspended for one year from the date this judgment becomes final and conclusive.

Punishment of the crime

No person shall interfere with rescue, transfer, first aid or medical treatment of an emergency patient by emergency medical personnel by means of violence, intimidation, deceptive scheme, force or other means.

피고인은 2019. 2. 11. 21:39경 경남 함양군 B에 있는 C병원 응급실 안에서 다리를 다쳐 후송된 피고인의 지인 D에게 진통제를 놓아달라고 그곳 당직의사인 피해자 E에게 수회 요구하였으나, 피해자로부터 ‘환자가 진통제 맞기를 거부해서 임의로 놓을 수가 없다‘는 취지의 말을 듣자 막무가내로 진통제를 놓아달라고 하였고, 이에 피해자로부터 진료에 방해가 되니 나가달라는 요청을 수회 받았음에도 나가지 않고 피해자로부터 “친보호자가 아니면 나가세요. 진료 방해하지 말고 나가세요. 당신 이름이 뭡니까.”라는 말을 듣자 피해자에게 “당신 니 나이 몇 살 쳐묵었냐. 임마. 경찰불러.”라고 말하며 삿대질을 하고 “하는 꼬라지 한번 봐라.”라고 말하며 오른쪽 손가락으로 피해자의 왼팔 부위를 찌르고, 피해자의 배 부위를 2회 찌르는 등 약 10분간 폭행의 방법으로 응급의료종사자의 응급환자에 대한 진료를 방해하였다.

Summary of Evidence

1. Defendant's legal statement;

1. A written statement of E;

1. Application of Acts and subordinate statutes to the investigation report (based on the analysis of CCTV images in the C Hospital);

1. Article 60 (2) 1 and Article 12 of the Emergency Medical Service Act concerning criminal facts and the choice of punishment, and the choice of imprisonment;

1. In light of the circumstances that interfere with the medical practice of emergency medical personnel required to be strictly protected for the reason of sentencing under Article 62(1) of the Criminal Act, the liability for the crime is not weak, the fact that there have been several records of punishment for the previous violent crimes, and the fact that the defendant recognized the defendant's mistake and reflects it, and the medical personnel who suffered the damage does not want to be punished against the defendant.