1. All appeals by the plaintiffs M, K, and EI against the defendants shall be dismissed.

2. Plaintiffs DE, BJ, DDR, DS, EK, CG, BI, G, and FD.

1. Basic facts

A. Status of the parties, etc. 1) A Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “A”).

AC apartment (hereinafter “instant apartment”) which is a multi-family housing with a scale of 3,000 square meters on the ground of 169,840 square meters on the land outside Busan Nam-gu, Busan, and 34 square meters.

(2) Of the instant apartment buildings, the Plaintiffs directly enter into a sales contract with A or acquire the status of the buyer from the existing buyer on the corresponding date indicated in the column of the “contract date” in the attached Tables 2 and 3 as to the corresponding apartment buildings indicated in the attached Schedules as to the corresponding apartment buildings in this case.

(3) The buyer of the apartment site in this case is located near Busan Metropolitan City tourism master, and the buyer of the apartment site in this case and the buyer of the apartment site in this case and the buyer of the apartment site in this case are located at AE, the Busan Metropolitan City, from August 5, 2004, with the approval of the housing construction project plan in this case and the approval of the announcement of the invitation of the apartment in this case on November 18, 2004. The apartment site in this case began to sell the apartment in this case from December 2, 2004.

A has promoted a housing construction project for the apartment site of this case and a marine park creation project for the above AF site (AI development project) as a connected project from around that time.

B. A and the defendant (hereinafter referred to as "the defendant, etc.") including the advertisement for sale in lots A and the defendant (hereinafter referred to as "A and the defendant") are about the apartment of this case from the time of obtaining approval for the housing construction project plan for the apartment of this case.