Defendant

All appeals filed by the Defendants A, B and prosecutor are dismissed.

1. Summary of grounds for appeal;

A. Each sentence sentenced by the lower court against the Defendants A and B (the two years of imprisonment, and the one year and six months of imprisonment) is too unreasonable.

B. The sentence imposed by the court below on the Defendants (Defendant A, B: the above, Defendant C: imprisonment with prison labor of one year and four months, two years of suspended execution, probation, and community service order 240 hours) is too uneased and unreasonable.

2. Determination

A. Due to the characteristics of the fraudulent act in this case, which falls under the "Singing" crime of Defendant A, B, and prosecutor's appeal against Defendant A, this constitutes a crime of fraud in this case, which causes serious harm not only to the victims, but also to our society as a whole, and which actually causes damage to an unspecified number of victims in a planned and systematic manner. In fact, the victims are not much injured due to the fraudulent act in this case. The extent of the defendants' participation in the whole crime cannot be deemed to be less than the extent of the defendants' participation in the crime by acting as an assistant staff recruitment, etc. in the crime in this case. In light of the circumstances of the crime in violation of the Act on the Punishment of Violence, etc. (joint injury) by Defendant A, it is not good, and the degree of injury of the victim A is not less than the extent of injury, etc., the defendants were forced to commit the crime in this case; the victim M., QA and the victim A were only punished before and after the occurrence of the crime in this case; the defendant T and the defendant's age of criminal punishment in this case did not have been agreed.