1. The plaintiff's respective claims against the defendants are all dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

1. Basic facts

A. The Plaintiff’s registered design is the Plaintiff’s owner of the next registered design (hereinafter “instant registered design”) with a company established on January 9, 2014 for the purpose of manufacturing, selling, etc. electronic tobacco.

1) Date/registration date/registration number: A product that is the subject of design of April 3, 2015 (No. 0817027)/ on September 16, 2015: (a) the description of the design of an electronic tobacco 3) shall include metal materials, glass materials and synthetic resin; (b) the product of this design shall be within the design, in combination with an electronic tobacco exhauster; (c) the quantity of liquid solution can be easily identified in the middle part of the product; (d) the quantity of liquid solution released into the design is 1.1.1.1.0 of the entire right-hand shape of the design; (d) the size of the design shall be 1.2.0 of the drawings, expressed in the shape of the entire design; and (e) the drawings shall be 16.1.0 of the map, expressed in the shape of the design, expressed in the shape of the design; and (e) the drawings shall be 1.4.1.6 times of the map, expressed in the shape of the design.

B. The Defendants’ products 1) sell electronic tobacco and electronic tobacco in the name of “E”. Defendant A is operating “E G store” on the F building and the first floor of the Seoul Jung-gu, Seoul, and the wife (the Defendant C, the wife, together with Defendant C, in Seocho-gu, Seoul, H and the first floor.