Text
1. The plaintiff's primary claim and the conjunctive claim against the defendants are all dismissed.
2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the Plaintiff.
Reasons
1. The Plaintiff’s assertion: (a) around November 23, 2013 to November 2014, the Plaintiff supplied 39,959,470 won in total to a company jointly operated by the Defendants; (b) the Defendants did not receive KRW 65,89,470 out of the price of the said goods; and (c) the Defendants jointly and severally seek payment of KRW 35,70,000 out of the price of the said unpaid goods to the Plaintiff; and (d) Defendant C and D did not operate a joint business; and (c) Defendant C and D lent the business name to the Defendant, even if the Defendants were to have received the said goods from the Plaintiff, and Defendant C and D jointly and severally liable as the nominal business owner; and (c) Defendant C and D jointly jointly liable to compensate the Defendants for the accrued amount of KRW 35,70,000 out of the price of the said goods.
2. First of all, according to the Plaintiff’s claim against Defendant B, according to the health care unit, Gap evidence Nos. 1-1 through 301, Gap evidence Nos. 4-1 through 5, and each court’s order to submit tax information to the National Tax Service, the Plaintiff’s transaction with Defendant B, which the Plaintiff traded with the supply of beverages, etc., and Nonghyup LA club E from June 2014 to December 2014, each of the electronic tax invoices amounting to KRW 125,702,60 in total with the “F” registered as Defendant C’s business operator, and KRW 45,43,370 in total with the “F” amounting to KRW 45,43,370 in total, and each of the above receipts issued by Defendant C, and each of the above receipts issued by Defendant Nos. 28,13,700, K and Home PP Co., Ltd., Ltd. (hereinafter “L28,709, etc.”).