1. The Defendants: (a) each of the Plaintiff A, KRW 3,289,770, KRW 500,000, and each of them from November 12, 2013.

1. Facts of recognition;

A. The plaintiff A is a resident of the Busan Shipping Daegu E apartment (hereinafter "the apartment of this case"), and the plaintiff B is the husband of the plaintiff, and the defendant C is the chairperson of the council of occupants' representatives of the apartment of this case and the director of the management office of the apartment of this case.

B. On May 31, 2013, Plaintiff A, following the occupancy of the instant apartment, had conflicts arising in the course of raising an objection against the fact that the excursion ship cost, which was not used by himself, was imposed on the Defendants, and the Plaintiffs and the Defendants had frequent disputes.

C. On August 26, 2013, at the entrance of the apartment management office of this case, Defendant C: (a) had been injured by Defendant C, a manager of the apartment management office, on the ground that in the process of examining the contents of the apartment management fee to Defendant D related to the apartment management fee, Defendant C expressed Defendant C’s desire to “old age and age” to Defendant C, on the following grounds: (b) caused the Plaintiff’s head at one time at the head of the Plaintiff C; (c) caused the Plaintiff’s head to be “old age and age” to be “old age and age,” and (d) caused the Plaintiff’s injury to Defendant C, in a way that the number of treatment days cannot be known to the Plaintiff’s head at one time at one hand and two handbags; and (d) around 09:30 on September 5, 2013, the apartment management office of this case, “A, a representative of the Myeon road, retired from his cell phone text messages, and caused the Plaintiff’s chest, etc. to the Defendant C’s chest.

Defendant C.

A person who was prosecuted for committing the same crime as described in the paragraph was convicted of a fine of KRW 500,000 on May 26, 2014.

(Resan District Court's East Branch of the District Court 2014, 39). (e)

At around 18:00 on August 23, 2013, Defendant C insulting the Plaintiff A by stating, “I ambling, singing, singing, singinginging, and ging away, snow,” to the Plaintiff at the seat of the Plaintiff B, Defendant D, and other management office personnel, etc., on the ground that the Plaintiff expressed the Plaintiff’s desire to the Defendant C, and insulting the Plaintiff on September 27, 2013.”