1. The plaintiff's claim of this case is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

1. Facts of recognition;

A. The plaintiff worked as a senior clerk at the Busan District Court from September 18, 1979 to October 13, 1990. The plaintiff married on February 3, 1995 and divorced on November 9, 2004.

On the other hand, D and E were parents of C, who were the Plaintiff’s head and the mother.

B. Around 195, the Defendant, along with F and G, asked E to resolve the H’s sale-related case (hereinafter “H case”), issued related documents and tools for each household, and paid KRW 19,00,000 under the pretext of the start-up amount, prepared a loan certificate stating that “The Defendant received KRW 19,00,000,000 from E” should have received the cash custody certificate, but “The Defendant borrowed KRW 19,00,000 from E.”

C. Meanwhile, the defendant is the plaintiff.

On July 3, 2008, the Busan High Court case 2007Na21382, which filed a loan certificate against E with the Busan High Court 2007Na21382, on the loan certificate of 19,00,000 won against E was presented as a witness and taken an oath on July 3, 2008, and the defendant's (E)'s agent's "if the balance is appropriate for any balance of the service at a price for the service," "I would like to give much time if the balance is not settled, and if the balance has been resolved, I would like to know this amount because it had been settled and it was well known that it would have been settled," and "I would like to answer it to the presiding judge's "I would like to answer it," "I would like to answer to the question of whether I would give money to Defendant E if it is not in money."

On August 14, 2008, the above court rendered a judgment dismissing the appeal of E, the appellant. D.

After that, on May 24, 2011, the Plaintiff was requested by Changwon District Court 201Da1538, the Plaintiff, as Changwon District Court 201, for the settlement of H case and the preparation of litigation documents, and was F and G.